Insurance Journal  Dec 17  Comment 
A worker was killed Tuesday in a Kentucky mine owned by Patriot Coal Co., the company’s third such fatality this year. Eli Eldridge, 34, of Sturgis, Kentucky died after he was struck by a vehicle shuttling coal to the feeder … The article...
Insurance Journal  May 14  Comment 
The West Virginia coal mine where a collapse this week killed two workers had “chronic compliance issues” and received numerous citations from inspectors last year, federal authorities said on Tuesday. The Patriot Coal Corp.’s Brody Mine No....
Benzinga  Dec 18  Comment 
Peabody Energy (NYSE: BTU) today affirmed that the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Missouri has entered an order confirming Patriot Coal's plan of reorganization, and Patriot Coal has announced the successful completion of exit...
Reuters  Dec 17  Comment 
Patriot Coal Corp said it would emerge from Chapter 11 bankruptcy on Wednesday, after months of wrangling with its unionized workforce and former parent Peabody Energy Corp over cost cuts.     
Wall Street Journal  Dec 17  Comment 
The Bankruptcy Court approval of Patriot Coal's reorganization plan clears the way for the coal-mining company to exit Chapter 11.
Reuters  Nov 6  Comment 
(Corrects 2nd paragraph to reflect that Patriot, not Peabody, fought with its union)
Benzinga  Oct 24  Comment 
The U.S. Mine, Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) today notified Patriot Coal Corporation (OTC: PCXCQ) that a Pattern of Violations (POV) exists at the Brody No. 1 mine, located in Boone County, West Virginia.  Patriot acquired Brody...
Wall Street Journal  Oct 10  Comment 
Patriot Coal has reached dual settlements in its Chapter 11 case that will serve as the foundation for its plan to exit bankruptcy and provide $400 million in funding for retiree health benefits through 2017.


Patriot Coal (PCX) is the third largest coal producer in the eastern United States.[1] Because coal is expensive to transport (in some cases, transportation costs can account for up to 70% the cost of delivered coal),[2] most coal is mined near where it is used - usually to power electricity plants and make steel. Therefore, to cater to the eastern U.S. market, Patriot Coal has operations in the eastern U.S., namely Central Appalachia, Northern Appalachia, and the Illinois Basin.

Although coal is less expensive than other energy sources, it also creates more pollution, and environmental repercussions of coal are a significant concern, especially with the advent of new, clean, and cheap energy sources, such as solar power and wind energy. The advent of legislation such as the cap-and-trade system suggests that governments are pushing for cleaner sources of energy, such as natural gas and renewables.

Company Overview

Patriot Coal produces coal for electricity generation and metallurgical quality coal for steel manufacturing.Patriot Coal controls around 1.3 billion tons of proven coal reserves, making it the third largest producer and marketer of coal in the eastern United States.[3]

The type of coal used in steel-making is referred to as metallurgical-quality coal and is distinguished by its high carbon content as well as various other chemical attributes. Metallurgical-quality coal is generally higher in heat content (as measured in Btus), and is better for both electricity generation and steel production, making it more expensive.[4]

Business & Financial Metrics[5]

In 2009, PCX generated a net income of $127.2 million on revenues of $2.05 billion. This represents a 10.7% decrease in net income against a 23.6% increase in total revenues from 2008, when the company earned $142.7 million on $1.65 billion in revenue.

Business Segments[6]

Patriot's mining and coal operations are divided into two regions: Appalachia and the Illinois Basin:

  • Appalachia (84.4% of total revenues): In southern West Virginia, Patriot Coal has five company-operated mines and many contractor-operated mines, all of which are handled by four coal preparation plants. In northern West Virginia, Patriot has one company-operated mine, handled by one preparation plant.Appalachia's mining operations are located at the Big Mountain mine, the Rocklick mine, the Wells mine, the Kanawha Eagle mine, and a Federal mine.[7]
  • Illinois Basin (13.2% of total revenues): In the Illinois Basin, Patriot Coal has four company-operated mines handled by three preparation plants. The Illinois Basin's mining operations are located at the Highland mine, the Bluegrass mine, the Dodge Hill mine, and the Big Run mine.[8]


Coal as an energy source

Coal is the most abundant fossil fuel produced in the United States. The United States has the world's largest known coal reserves (about 263.8 billion tons). This is enough coal to last approximately 225 years at today's level of use. However, coal is a nonrenewable energy source that takes millions of years to create. Analysts project that U.S. utilities will increase consumption by 39% by 2030. Globally, coal consumption increased 30% in the past five years alone, and it is projected to increase another 1.1 billion tons over the next 10 years.[9]

Coal is a highly cost-efficient source of energy. When burned to produce electricity, coal-powered plants tend to have an average efficiency of 33% energy-to-electricity output. About 92 percent of the coal used in the United States is for generating electricity. However, coal can also be used for various industry applications, for making steel, and for export (more than half of exported coal is used for making steel). Patriot Coal distributes coal for generating electricity as well as metallurgical-quality coal for steelmaking purposes.[10]

Key Trends and Forces

Price fluctuations of competing fuels drive demand for coal

One of coal's competitors is natural gas. Since coal is cheaper and its price has increased less than that of natural gas, coal continues to lead the market for electricity generation. If the price of natural gas falls sharply, demand for coal is likely to drop and demand for natural gas will increase.

However, natural gas is a cleaner burning alternative to coal, and composes 19% to annual US electricity production.[11] Natural gas is therefore increasingly gaining market share over coal.

Commodity cycles make consistency difficult for Patriot Coal

Coal is a commodity and is therefore subject to commodity cycles driven by the forces of supply and demand. In times of excess supply, coal prices fall, and in times of rising demand, coal prices rise. Presently, demand for energy is soaring, especially in developing nations like China and India that harbor massive populations. This causes global coal prices to rise. While Patriot Coal does not export coal overseas In times of commodity booms, coal companies achieve increased profit margins as revenues soar in proportion to coal prices. However, in times of commodity busts, coal companies suffer lower net profits. Since there is not much product discrimination in the commodity market, Patriot Coal's coal is virtually indistinguishable from its competitors' coal; coal companies are therefore price competitors that must lower prices to achieve a competitive advantage. Patriot Coal is therefore vulnerable to price cycles; Patriot has no control over the price of coal, which is subject to greater market forces.

Environmental concerns and regulatory legislation hinder Patriot Coal as incentive for renewable energy grows

The adjacent figure indicates that coal is one of the dirtiest forms of energy production. Coal produces nearly 1200 kilotons of CO2 per terawatt of electricity produced. Other cleaner forms of energy, such as natural gas, wind energy, solar power, and hydroelectric power produce much less CO2 but also cost much more than coal. However, legislation has been passed to subsidize renewable energy sources while capping on CO2 emission by establishing incentives such as carbon trading. The Clean Air Act[12] and the Carbon Principles (set by Citigroup, JP Morgan, and Morgan Stanley)[13] are two examples of legislation and policies that seek to discourage dependence on coal as an energy source that have increased costs for coal producers such as Patriot Coal.

The Renewable Portfolios Standard (RPS), a regulatory policy requiring US states to increase the production and use of renewable energy sources, is likely to pose a future threat to Patriot Coal's revenues as states increase their percentages of cleaner energy. For example, Pennsylvania has planned to obtain 18% of its energy from clean sources by 2020, and Illinois has planned to obtain 25% by 2025.[14] Currently, there are 27 states and the District of Columbia that have RPS policies in place, and this number is likely to grow.[15] As legislative measures increase pressure on coal production, Patriot Coal's profits are likely to decrease.

PCX produces all its coal very close to its customers

A significant issue most coal companies face is transportation costs. Coal is expensive to transport (in some cases, transportation costs can account for up to 70% the cost of delivered coal), [16]. Since Patriot Coal only supplies coal for electricity generation to US power plants, international transportation is not an issue the company faces (while other coal companies, such as Peabody Peabody Energy (BTU), which has operations in Australia, face high coal transportation costs). Additionally, all of Patriot Coal's reserves are located within a 500 mile radius of the majority of electricity-generating power plants and steel producers in the United States. [17] By being in close proximity to buyers of coal, Patriot minimizes its transportation costs, thereby increasing potential profit margins.


As a small, newly spun-off company, Patriot Coal faces competition from other small US coal producers that operate in similar regions and have comparable market caps. Two such companies that represent Patriot's most direct competitors include International Coal Group (ICO) and James River Coal Company (JRCC).[18] Since coal is a commodity good, there is no real product differentiation between competitors, resulting in coal companies engaging in price competition. This leads to competitive price cycles and, as a result, relatively low profit margins.[19]

PCX's competitors include International Coal Group (ICO) and James River Coal Company (JRCC).


  1. Patriot Coal Declares 2-For-1 Stock Split and Expands Board
  2. World Coal Institute: Coal Transportation
  3. Patriot Coal Declares 2-For-1 Stock Split and Expands Board
  4. ICO 10K, Page 4
  5. PCX 2009 10-K pg. 43  
  6. 6.0 6.1 PCX 2009 10-K pg. 47  
  7. Patriot Coal 2007 Annual Report
  8. Patriot Coal 2007 Annual Report
  9. Energy Information Administration - Coal
  10. Energy Information Administration - Coal
  11. Foundation Coal Annual Report
  12. Clean Air Act
  13. Environmental Leader - Article
  14. EERE State Activities
  15. EERE State Activities
  16. World Coal Institute: Coal Transportation
  17. Peabody-Patriot Form 10, page 1
  18. Patriot Coal 10K, Page 37
  19. [ICO Competition Report]
Wikinvest © 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012. Use of this site is subject to express Terms of Service, Privacy Policy, and Disclaimer. By continuing past this page, you agree to abide by these terms. Any information provided by Wikinvest, including but not limited to company data, competitors, business analysis, market share, sales revenues and other operating metrics, earnings call analysis, conference call transcripts, industry information, or price targets should not be construed as research, trading tips or recommendations, or investment advice and is provided with no warrants as to its accuracy. Stock market data, including US and International equity symbols, stock quotes, share prices, earnings ratios, and other fundamental data is provided by data partners. Stock market quotes delayed at least 15 minutes for NASDAQ, 20 mins for NYSE and AMEX. Market data by Xignite. See data providers for more details. Company names, products, services and branding cited herein may be trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The use of trademarks or service marks of another is not a representation that the other is affiliated with, sponsors, is sponsored by, endorses, or is endorsed by Wikinvest.
Powered by MediaWiki