Wachovia is trading at a $5.50/share premium to tangible capital/common share of ~$14.50, calculated as follows:
- Common Share Count: 2,138 million (1,992 at quarter-end plus 146 issued in April)
- Tangible Capital: $31.0 billion (quarter-end book value of $78.0 less intangibles of $45.1 and preferred of $5.8, plus proceeds of $3.9bn from common issued in April)
This premium represents 4.3% of low-cost deposits of ~$278 billion, below the minimum premium of 5% an acquirer would likely pay. This value-based analysis fails if you believe write-downs and credit losses will absorb the entire go-forward earnings power of Wachovia (because then book value will fall further).
I do not think this likely (and will post later on why) hence WB looks like a buy to me.