close
Edit Metric
Company
Value
Source
Source URL
Notes
Cancel
 
close
Edit  |  History
Details
Company:
Value :
Source:
Source URL:
Notes:
 
Feedback  |  FAQ
Get involved
Calpine Corporation is an electric utility that produces 30% of its energy from Geothermal sources (the remainder is produced with natural gas). Government subsidies for alternative energy - such as California's Renewable Portfolio Standard requiring that 20% of the state's electricity come from renewable energy sources by 2010 - is a major boost for technologies like Calpine's, which also benefits from government subsidies that support the massive infrastructure investments geothermal plants require.

Geothermal only produces about 30% of Calpine's revenues, however; the balance (70%) comes from natural gas. Calpine's dependence on gas means its margins are heavily dependent on natural gas prices, which have fluctuated unpredictably over the past few years. The volatility of natural gas is offset, however, by the flexibility of gas-powered plants, which let the company more easily adjust electricity production. In regions where temperature fluctuates heavily through the day and over a year, like the West Coast and Texas, these plants let the company cut operating costs by reducing production when it isn't necessary.

Contents

[edit] Business and Financials

Calpine is an energy company with 24,000 MW of generating capacity, including 60 natural gas powered facilities across the U.S. and 17 geothermal plants in the Northern California Geysers region[1]. Its primary customers are industrial electricity users, government agencies, and electric utilities; 10% of its revenues come from the California Department of Water Resources.

Calpine Financials ($ Millions)
2004 2005 2006 2007
Revenue 8,645 10,302 6,937 7,970
Net Income (loss) (243) (9,939) (1,765) 2,693


In December 2005, Calpine filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The company had $17 billion in debt[2], and after the Enron scandal, the collapse of the power market led to investor examination of power company finances - and an eventual run on power stocks, causing Calpine's price to drop from $50/share to $0.30/share between 2001 and 2004. Calpine emerged from bankruptcy in February of 2008, resuming trading on the NYSE under the ticker "CPN"[3].

Calpine Production Data for 2007[4]
West Texas Southeast North Other Consolidated
Net Interest (in Peaking Megawatts) 7,246 7,487 6,254 2,822 - 2,3809
Total Number of Projects 43 12 12 10 - 77
Commodity Margin 1,196 500 268 283 (22) 2,225

Most of Calpine's operations are in its "West" segment, which spans California, Arizona, Colorado, and Oregon, as well as its Texas segment. The company's margins were highest in the West, possibly because of the price premium attached to energy from the company's geothermal plants in California. The West and Texas also have higher energy prices because of seasonal temperature fluctuations, leading to higher sales prices for Calpine.

[edit] NRG Energy Made an Unsolicited Acquisition Offer

In May, 2008, NRG Energy made an offer to purchase Calpine worth $10.8 billion. At the end of the month, Calpine rejected the offer, and NRG has stated that it has no plans to raise the bid.

[edit] Trends and Forces

[edit] Calpine Recently Emerged from Bankruptcy

On January 31st, Calpine finished its Chapter 11 proceedings, and started trading on the New York Stock Exchange once again. The company went bankrupt in 2005 because of debt incurred through financing of 70,000 MW expansion projects that was cut short by the Enron scandal and the subsequent power market crash. In the process of coming out of bankruptcy, the company cut $7 billion in debt, closed 19 offices, and laid off 1,100 employees. Calpine argues that, despite the regulated nature of the power market, it will be able to turn a profit because its power plants meet the "green" demands of modern energy consumers; though natural gas is rarely considered to be environmentally-friendly, it is far cleaner than its alternative, coal, while geothermal energy really is a "green" technology. Calpine is also playing it safe to avoid another financing crisis, by increasing its capacity incrementally; the company announced plans to add between 1,285 and 1,601 MW - a far cry from the ambitious 70,000 MW that put the company in the red[5].

[edit] Calpine's Margins Move with Natural Gas Prices

Out of the $7.97 billion in revenue that Calpine pulled for 2007, $5.68 billion went to paying for fuel and purchased energy[6]. Since over 23 of the 24 GW of energy that Calpine and its subsidiaries can produce comes from gas plants, most of these fuel costs stemmed from the purchase of natural gas. Over the past few years, natural gas prices have been very volatile, rising to record highs, dropping, then rising again. The company sells power in long-term contracts; when gas prices are high, Calpine's margins shrink; when prices fall, margins increase. Exposure to the volatility of the natural gas market, which moves at the slightest event - from a new reserve discovery to the threat of terrorism - makes Calpine's margins almost as volatile. Furthermore, a long-term decline in the availability of natural gas, due to any range of causes from pipeline infrastructure damage to peak oil and the decline in fossil fuels, would greatly damage Calpine's ability to produce and deliver electricity profitably.

[edit] Utilities Regulation Can Affect Calpine's Energy Prices

Calpine's margins are further affected by the regulation of electric utilities in the U.S. and Canada. Regional governments set electricity prices to ensure both profitability for utilities companies and accessibility for all consumers. Because of utilities regulation, the prices that energy companies charge the utilities companies must be low enough for the utilities to make a profit; this leads to price competition and depressed margins for the whole energy industry. Calpine remedies this problem by selling energy that is considered "cleaner" than many other types; natural gas does not emit the particulate pollution that coal and oil do, and it has no dangerous wastes, like nuclear. Geothermal energy is almost completely clean. With cleaner electricity generation methods, Calpine can compete based on electricity users' preferences, as well as on regulatory grounds; without the need to install costly scrubbers and filters, it can sell electricity for slightly cheaper than its coal competitors.

[edit] Calpine's Use of Natural Gas Makes it Regionally Competitive

Utilities regulation can vary by region, depending on electricity use patterns and the dominance of certain energy sources. Calpine's main markets are in the Western U.S. and Texas, where electricity use tends to come in peaks and valleys because of temperature changes depending on season and time of day. These regions tend to see higher set electricity prices, making natural gas plants useful; though gas is more expensive than most base-load plants, it can be used to provide variable amounts of energy, allowing Calpine to reduce production (and costs) when demand is low. This allows the company to maximize the price at which it sells its electricity.

[edit] Legislative Support for Renewable Energy Makes Calpine's Geothermal Plants More Competitive

State governments across the U.S. are implementing legislation to encourage alternative energy production, due to political pressure from public concerns about climate change, oil prices, and energy independence. Twenty-six states have set Renewable Portfolio Standards that set varying targets for the amount of energy to be obtained from renewable sources by certain dates. California, where all of Calpine's geothermal facilities are located, has targeted reaching 20% renewable energy usage by 2010[7]. What this means is that there is now a "premium" on the price of all energy that comes from renewable sources in California, including Calpine's geothermal plants. Electric utilities are scrambling to reach the allotted mix, and Calpine has benefited both from the growing demand for renewables and the hike in geothermal energy prices caused by it. In February 2008, for example, the company made a deal to sell 175 MW of geothermally-produced electricity to western utilities powerhouse PG&E - a deal that will bring the ratio of PG&E's renewable electricity contracts to the required 20%[8].

[edit] Climate Change Regulations Have the Potential to Increase Calpine's Costs

Despite the climate-friendly nature of Calpine's geothermal plants, with just 725 MW[9] out of 24,000 MW[10], they amount to just about 3% of Calpine's total energy mix. The rest comes from natural gas, which is cleaner than coal or oil in terms of particulate emissions but still emits large quantities of greenhouse gases. In the event that the U.S. government, or individual state governments, levy carbon emissions limits, Calpine's operations will be significantly compromised. For this reason, Calpine actively lobbies against carbon control initiatives.

[edit] Competition

As an energy company, Calpine faces a wide range of competitors.

  • Pacific Gas & Electric - PG&E is a utilities companies that provides electricity to 5.1 million customers and gas to 4.3 million customers. It owns nuclear, hydroelectric, and fossil-fuel power plants with a total generating capacity of 6,271 MW[11].
  • Dynegy - With 19,156 MW of natural gas-powered capacity, Dynegy's youth (it incorporated in 2007) has not stopped it from expanding operations across thirteen states[12].
  • FirstEnergy - FirstEnergy's holdings include eight electric utilities that operate in Ohio, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. Its total generating capacity is 14,127 MW, 54% of which comes from coal, 28.5% of which comes from nuclear, 10.9% of which comes from oil and natural gas, 3.3% of which comes from hydroelectric, and 3.3% of which comes from the company's interest in Ohio Valley Electric Corporation[13].

As one of the few major geothermal operators in the U.S., Calpine competes with:

  • Ormat Technologies - Ormat is the only pure-play geothermal energy company in the U.S., and had 407 MW installed at the end of 2006[14], with 210 MW being installed at the end of 2007[15].
  • Chevron - With an installed geothermal capacity of 1,273 MW in Indonesia and the Philippines, Chevron supplies 13% of the global geothermal energy supply - and is the largest private geothermal energy company in the world[16].

[edit] Notes

  1. CPN 2007 10-K, Overview, Page 2
  2. USA Today: "Calpine files for bankruptcy protection"
  3. Cleantech.com: "Calpine emerges from Chapter 11"
  4. http://sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/916457/000119312508042308/d10k.htm#tx19164_10 CPN 2007 10-K, Pages 12 and 48]
  5. http://www.redorbit.com/news/business/1254462/calpine_powers_up_for_a_comeback_after_painful_financial_retooling/
  6. Calpine Press Release: "Calpine Reports 2007 Full-Year Results"
  7. Descriptions of State Renewable Portfolio Standards
  8. Mercury News: "PG&E buys more steam power from Calpine"
  9. Reuters.com, Full Description: Calpine Corp
  10. CPN 2007 10-K, Overview, Page 2
  11. PCG 2007 10-K, Page 17
  12. Reuters.com: Full Description: Dynegy Inc
  13. Reuters.com, Full Description: FirstEnergy Corp
  14. Reuters.com, Full Description: Ormat Technologies
  15. Ormat.com Press Release: Ormat Technologies, Inc. Reports Third Quarter 2007 Results
  16. Chevron Geothermal Website
The Shelf
Contributions
Help make Wikinvest better! Learn how to get involved. And create an account to build your reputation.
Did you know…?
Bookmarks
Worried about pump and dump?
We review changes
for stock spam
Want to make Wikinvest better?
We need your help,
contribute today
Do you write software?
We are recruiting
the best engineers
Like Wikinvest?
Spread the word —
Tell your friends!
Wikinvest © 2006, 2007, 2008. Use of this site is subject to express Terms of Service, Privacy Policy, and Disclaimer. By continuing past this page, you agree to abide by these terms. Any information provided by Wikinvest, including but not limited to company data, competitors, business analysis, market share, sales revenues and other operating metrics, earnings call analysis, conference call transcripts, industry information, or price targets should not be construed as research, trading tips or recommendations, or investment advice and is provided with no warrants as to its accuracy. Stock market data, including US and International equity symbols, stock quotes, share prices, earnings ratios, and other fundamental data is provided by data partners. Stock market quotes delayed at least 15 minutes for NASDAQ, 20 mins for NYSE and AMEX. See data providers for more details. Company names, products, services and branding cited herein may be trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The use of trademarks or service marks of another is not a representation that the other is affiliated with, sponsors, is sponsored by, endorses, or is endorsed by Wikinvest.
Powered by MediaWiki